What happened

A plan to pick the president by the national popular vote is closer than ever to taking effect. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, a deal among states to hand their electoral votes to the winner of the nationwide vote rather than the winner in each state, could cross the 270-vote line it needs after this month's midterm elections.

Democrats' big wins in November put five more states under full Democratic control next year: Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada and Wisconsin. Those five hold 61 electoral votes between them. The compact already counts 222. Any four of the five joining would push it past 270, the number needed for it to kick in.

Governors and incoming governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have said they are open to signing the legislation. Others have not weighed in yet. Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs backed the idea in the past but has not said recently whether the state's new Democratic majorities should sign on. Her office did not respond to NPR before publication.

No Republican-led state has joined the compact, and the party is split on the idea.

Why it matters

The compact would change how America chooses a president without amending the Constitution. Supporters say that is the point. A constitutional amendment to scrap the Electoral College failed in 1969, and very few amendments have come close to passing since. The compact is their workaround.

Backers argue it would force presidential candidates to campaign across the whole country instead of pouring time and money into a handful of battleground states. It would also make every vote count the same, no matter where it was cast. Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to National Popular Vote, the group pushing the compact, told NPR he has "never been more confident that 63% of American voters can get what they want in the 2028 presidential election, which is a national popular vote for president," citing Pew polling.

But the states being asked to sign on are the same battlegrounds that gain the most from the current system. Their leaders will have to decide whether to give up that leverage, and whether they want to be the state that tips the compact over the line.

The midterms also left the country divided over how elections are run. [Most Republicans doubt the midterms were fair, according to a new poll](/article/most-republicans-doubt-midterms-were-fair-poll), a reminder that any change to how the president is chosen will land in a climate of low trust.

What it means for the US

If the compact takes effect before 2028, the next presidential race would look very different. Candidates would chase votes in big safe states like California and Texas as hard as they chase them in Pennsylvania and Michigan. Battleground states would lose the outsized attention and campaign spending they now enjoy.

For American voters, the practical effect is simple: the candidate with the most votes nationwide would win, even if they lost under the old Electoral College math. That has happened five times in American history, most recently in 2016.

The change would also reshape how campaigns are run. Instead of a few swing states deciding everything, both parties would need a genuinely national operation, a shift that could change which issues get attention and where candidates spend their time.

There is a catch. The compact would hand enormous weight to the national vote count while leaving the counting itself in the hands of 51 separate state election systems. Critics say that mismatch is a problem waiting to happen.

What happens next

Watch the state legislatures in Pennsylvania and Nevada first. Their governors have signalled openness, and bills could move early next year. The other three states are less clear, and Arizona's governor has gone quiet on the issue.

Legal challenges are near certain. Scholars point to the Constitution's compact clause, which bars states from entering agreements with each other without Congress's consent except in narrow emergencies. Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, argues the clean way to do this is a constitutional amendment under Article 5. "You need to do that through a constitutional amendment, because only a constitutional amendment can address the legal and practical challenges," he said.

John Koza, chairman of National Popular Vote, disagrees. He says no new federal bureaucracy is needed: states already certify their vote counts, and "all that has to be done is add them up."

Opponents such as Save Our States warn that without the Electoral College, politics would tilt toward regional blocs and deepen the country's divides.

Supporters hope the compact clears its hurdles in time for 2028. The [Democrats' 14-point House win](/article/democrats-14-point-house-win-largest-50-years), the largest in 50 years, gives them the state-level power to try. Whether they use it is the next question.