What happened

US negotiators have raised a new idea for ending the war in Ukraine: Kyiv gives up the last ground it still holds in the eastern Donbas region, and in return Ukraine joins NATO. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said so on Saturday, after meeting the American envoys in Dublin.

"The Americans raised a question: 'What if Ukraine joins Nato? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?' This was the first time this had been raised," Zelensky told reporters.

It is a sharp turn. Until now, US officials had said Ukrainian membership of the alliance was off the table. Zelensky said the proposal made him believe that "Nato is back on the agenda." He added a warning, though: "You have also heard Putin's signals, and this is an extremely difficult conversation."

The idea came from US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, who travelled to Dublin on Thursday to meet Zelensky after a round of talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow. Zelensky said he would put any proposal to a referendum if it came with security guarantees, no limits on Ukraine's military, and money to rebuild the country.

Why it matters

The swap would trade land for the one thing Kyiv has wanted since the war began: a NATO guarantee that deters another Russian invasion. Ukraine has long sought membership, but the US and others opposed it while Russia called another NATO member on its border unacceptable.

For Kyiv, the price is steep. Russia already occupies roughly a fifth of Ukrainian territory, including most of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions that make up the Donbas. Giving up the small portions Ukraine still controls there would be symbolically heavy. It would amount to accepting the Donbas as Russian, after Zelensky had spoken of retaking Russian-held territory in four regions, plus Crimea, which Moscow annexed in 2014.

Moscow, meanwhile, has not moved. Comments by Putin and Kremlin officials suggest Russia's position has not shifted, and its demands for territory and neutrality still far exceed what Ukraine is prepared to consider. Moscow has previously proposed limits on the size of Ukraine's military, territorial concessions and guaranteed neutrality as conditions of a peace deal. Ukraine rejected them, arguing such limits would leave it unable to stop a future invasion. The latest round of talks follows [Putin's higher demands for peace after the US talks](/article/putin-raises-demands-for-ukraine-peace-after-us-talks), which set the bar for what Moscow expects.

There are signs the two sides can still find common ground. Last month, First Lady Melania Trump brokered a temporary ceasefire in the Kherson region so evacuations and aid deliveries could go ahead.

What it means for the US

Washington is now driving the negotiation, and the idea on the table puts the US at the center of the deal. NATO membership for Ukraine would mean an American-backed defense commitment to Kyiv, so any agreement would land directly on US security policy and on the American taxpayer if reconstruction funds are part of it.

The talks also touch American wallets through fuel. The latest round follows weeks of friction over Ukrainian strikes on oil facilities deep inside Russia, which President Donald Trump asked Kyiv to pause so Russian diesel could keep flowing and ease global fuel prices. Those prices have been rising since the US and Israel attacked Iran in February.

The mood between the two capitals is strained. Zelensky has accused US officials of limiting Ukraine's Starlink internet service, which its forces use to coordinate defensive operations, while Trump has said it is "time for Ukraine to get a new president" and called for fresh elections. Elections are suspended while Ukraine is under martial law, but Zelensky has said he would hold them within months of a peace deal and would give up the presidency in exchange for NATO membership. That friction was already visible when [Ukraine reported Starlink curbs as US envoys met Putin in Moscow](/article/ukraine-reports-starlink-curbs-as-us-envoys-meet-putin-in-moscow).

What happens next

Nothing is agreed yet. The proposal is a question raised in talks, not a written deal, and both sides still have to accept terms that neither has accepted before. Zelensky has set his conditions: security guarantees, a military free of limits, and rebuilding funds, with a referendum to follow.

The next test is whether Moscow softens its demands on territory and neutrality. Until it does, the gap between what Russia wants and what Ukraine will give up remains the wall the talks keep hitting.